Baked Goods
At Chocolate in the Oven, we offer an array of nostalgic pastries while staying on trend with new and inventive desserts. From jumbo cupcakes, to flaky lobster tails, to our famous peanut butter buckeyes, we promise there is something for everyone. Our cases are filled daily with our homemade, made on-site baked goods and confections. Below are some customer favorites but be sure to visit for other holiday and seasonal items! We have many gluten-free items available daily.
Butter Cookies, Lemon Ricotta, Anise, Pignoli, Pecan, Coconut Macaroons (GF), Almond Horns (GF), Thumb Prints, Hamantashen, Rugalach, Black & White, Linzer, Flourless Chocolate (GF), Cowboy, Peanut Butter Crisp, Iced Oatmeal Raisin, Chocolate Chip, Assorted Biscotti, Lavender shortbread, French Macaroons, M&M
Cookies
Triple Chocolate Brownies, 7 Layer Magic Bars, Apricot Almond, Chocolate Chip Cheesecake, Raspberry Oat, Peanut Butter Bar, Gooey Butter Bar, Smores Bar
Brownies & Bars
Napoleons, Lobster Tails, Sfogliatelle, Cannolli, Tiramisu, Cream Puffs, Eclairs
Italian Pastry
Chocolate Bomb, NY, Flourless cheesecake cups,
Caramel Turtle Tart, Lemon Marscapone, Fruit Tarts, Raspberry Chocolate Ganache
Cheesecakes & Tarts
Pies & Tarts
Apple, blueberry, cherry, strawberry-rhubarb, mixed berry, coconut custard, lemon, chocolate cream, key lime, peanut butter, shoo-fly, pecan, strawberry
Homemade Candy
& Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Buckeyes, Honey Lavender Truffles, Wine Truffles, Chocolate covered pretzels, small batch ice cream